Skip to main content
Human Resources
Asked a question 6 months ago

This is an add-on to my last question. Would you recommend a Cash lifetime ISA or a stocks and shares lifetime ISA?

Where am I?

In Koody Community you can ask and answer questions and share your experience with others!

Both have their place and it depends on what you want the lifetime ISA for and your time horizon.

e.g. if you’re using it on a first home in the next few years - cash is probably the better choice as a S&S ISA risks being down when you need the money for a deposit. 

if this is just for retirement and you’re using the LISA to get the government bonus - a stocks and shares Lisa is better as it will on average return more over the long term and protects against inflation 



This answer won 500 Koody Coins

@Becca26 This really depends on your timeframe, the level of risk you're willing to take, and your goals (saving for a house or retirement).

Savings (cash LISA) is usually best if you know you'll want the money in a shorter time period, say less than 3/5 years. There's no risk to losing money with savings as you're given interest from the bank as your return.

Investing (S&S LISA) is usually for longer term plans, like minimum 5 years. If you invest money today and you want to buy a house next year, the market may be down over the next 12 months, which then if you withdrew the money to buy a house you're doing so at a loss. Having said that the market could go up in 12 months too but unlike savings you can't know how much return you'd get with investing. 5 years is usually mentioned as a good amount of time where the ups and downs of the market will average out where you're more likely to make some gains overall. Over a longer timeframe, these gains should be far more than the savings interest rates.

Either one you choose you're still getting 25% guaranteed bonus anyway